09/09/2021
With Hurricane Larry set to travel across the Avalon Peninsula with tropical storm force winds, here are my thoughts on potential damages to asphalt shingle roofs, and recommendations, including on what you should specify if a replacement roof should be necessary.
In 2010, Hurricane Igor caused 120 km/h winds and Insurance Bureau of Canada described Igor as one of Newfoundland’s most damaging storms: losses were about $65 million. As of 9:22 AM, Thursday, September 9th, Hurricane Larry is expected to deliver sustained winds near 120 km/h, with gusts up to 130 km/h.
Obviously we can expect this storm will bring extreme, damage causing winds. Roof planes with the most exposure to winds are at the highest risk, and shingles that are not laying flat are more likely to be damaged.
1. If your roof is at greater risk, take additional precautions to protect property that may be damaged due to the loss of the roof's ability shed water, such as covering or moving property.
Typically manufactures have exclusions in their limited warranties. For example: "Exclusions and Limitations: 1. Any damage that occurs during or after any improper application process, including one that fails to follow [the manufacturer's] printed application instructions." This means that your warranty may not be valid if the contractor does not follow both the manufacturer's directions, as well as that required by the National Building Code of Canada, and other applicable standards.
Unfortunately some roofs may require replacement. When hiring a contractor to install a new roof, it is important that the home owner verifies the contractor will follow the installation instructions. Furthermore, the homeowner should specify that high wind installation methods must be followed because this may also limit roof warranty, and also because it is uncommon for installers to do so. (If you lived in Newfoundland for any amount of time, you know the average windy day can blow the milk out of a cup of tea.)
2. Specify that the installer must follow application instructions (this may also include requirements for underlayment, high wind installation methods, starter strips, and additional adhesive).
3. Specify that the installer must follow the National Building Code of Canada, current edition (especially Section 9.26 - Roofing).
4. Specify that eaves protection is installed as per the NBCC 9.26.5.1, and extended, if required by the manufacturer. (Typically this is 300 to 600 mm beyond the interior surface of the exterior wall.)
5. Specify that shingles are installed following the optional directions for high wind installation methods. (See CASMA Technical Bulletin #11.)
6. Specify an underlayment is installed for the entire roof. (See CASMA Technical Bulletin #3.)
7. Specify the installation of a drip and rake edges. Note: This is often absent from roofs, and may require coordination with an eavestroughing installer to make the metal brake shapes. (See CASMA Technical Bulletin #25.)
8. Specify open valley installations where two roof planes meet. This is more durable than a closed valley (where shingles run continuously across the intersection of two roof planes). (See NBCC 9. 26. 4. 3)
9. Specify step flashing--not a continuous strip--at all raked roof to wall intersections (often this is where a sloped garage roof meets a second floor wall). Step flashing is required by the National Building Code, sentence 9. 26. 4. 5 (3).
10. Specify that a kick flashing is used where the bottom of a sloped roof ends before an adjacent wall. Water must be directed away from the wall such that it doesn't enter behind the cladding.
11. Obtain permits. Your municipal building inspector is your first resource should serious deficiencies in the installation be found.
12. Get it in writing.
13. Be prepared to pay more. The generally accepted standard roof installation, in this region, may not meet or exceed the requirements set by manufacturers or code requirements. Contractors may have increased costs in order to install the roof according to these specifications (correctly).
14. Let your friends and family know, especially #13. Our windy rainy province needs better roof installations.
If you have any questions, write them below. Good luck weathering the storm. - Robert Miller