06/08/2024
One common theme over the many years I have been on this board is this holy crusade against herbicides while promoting something far worse, which is salt or epsom salt mixed with soap and or vinegar as a benign, non-chemical w**d killer. Now, back to high school chemistry, if you can remember that far back.... salt, epsom salt, vinegar, and dish soap are all.... chemicals!
Putting any kind of salt down on our salty soil will absolutely kill the w**ds, along with all the soil biome (literally every microorganism), all the worms, all the mycorrhizae, etc. And not just for a day or a week. Salt of any kind can poison soil for years or even decades. When it dissolves and runs off, it poisons streams too (the lower Arkansas is so salty these days it can barely support agriculture). It's almost impossible to get rid of it once you put it down -- water it in, it will simply wick back to the surface as the soil dries. Vinegar also pH shocks the soil and will kill much soil life, although in the case of vinegar, the effects are not as permanent.
I'm not here to push herbicides on those who don't use them, but I can tell you that science says glyphosate breaks down in soil after a few weeks to a few months, and does not translocate well, so it tends to stay put where it is applied. I say this to point out that sometimes, falling for "meme science" can lead us to make worse decisions. The ideal option is always to pull or dig. But if you have a field full of invasive thistle and the state or county tells you to kill them, hand pulling 5 acres is not realistic for most.
Glyphosate IS overused (it is sprayed on your cereal crops to kill them for faster harvest) and often misused. Like so many other things, it can cause cancer if not handled correctly. But smoking causes cancer on a much more regular basis and tons of y'all smoke, and alcohol is a potent carcinogen that many imbibe daily. Just pointing out that fanaticism is the enemy of logic and reason. So is absolutism. The truth is often the grey area in between.
If you need to get rids of w**ds, your options are to pull them, or use some sort of chemical to get rid of them. Your choices to make, right? You get to make whichever choice works best for you -- but here's the kicker.... so does everyone else!
We may now begin the wringing of hands and angry outbursts directed at me. I'd say burn me in effigy as well, I'm told it's a very refreshing thing to do. ;) But seriously -- do whatever but please, ffs, do not put salt on your soil. That is all.