08/13/2026
Building Soil Part 5
Soil care as an art.
One can make the argument, as I will attempt to do here, that building soil is as much of an art as it science. In fact, I would argue, that it is best viewed as an art. The reason is that soil is so incredibly complex that one cannot keep track of all of the variables.
We will explore the various factors that make each individual soil what it is...
Soil type and texture are made up of five different components: sand, silt, loam, clay, and organic matter. The percentage of each of these determines the soil type and texture. Also note that each of these components is highly variable in and of itself. Not all sand is the same and neither are clay, silt, loam, or organic matter. Just by type alone soils are highly variable.
The next factor to consider is the soil nutrients. Soil contains eighteen nutrients and one antinutrient. Sulfur, Boron, Calcium, Chlorine, Copper, Cobalt, Phosphorus, Iron, Manganese, Magnesium, Molybdenum, Nickel, Nitrogen, Potassium, Selenium, Silicon, Sodium, and Zinc are all present in our soils and used by our plants. Another thing to consider is the presence of Aluminum which can inhibit plant uptake of copper, zinc, calcium, magnesium, manganese, potassium, iron, and phosphorus.
Each of the above elements are present in the soil at different amounts. Some soils have plenty of almost everything, and others are low in many nutrients. Take note that high amounts of one nutrient such as iron or nitrogen can restrict plant uptake of other nutrients. The interactions of these elements are incredibly complex. Another thing to consider is that just because an element is present in your soil does not mean it is available in a form your plants can absorb.
Microbes are what make those nutrients available to your plants in a form they can use. In a teaspoon of soil there are more than 10,000 species of microbes with a total population between 100 million and 1 billion. Microbes are also very location specific with the microbes 100 feet apart being slightly different in their makeup. Microbes transported from 50 miles away may be unable to live in your climate and even raising their elevation by 50 feet can kill off their numbers.
Think of microbe species like any large mammal. A house cat and a Siberian tiger are the same species, but are very different animals. Microbes are able to adapt very quickly by means of rapid reproduction. They can change their expression throughout the seasons and from season to season to adapt to changes in conditions. So even if there are "just" 10,000 species in a teaspoon of soil, there is much more variability than those numbers might indicate. It's mind boggling!
Climate and microclimates also affect how soils functions. Rainfall, temperature, slope, aspect (which direction a slope is facing), and sunlight all affect our soils.
Another factor that affects soil is the plants growing in it. Plants can alter what type of microbes live in that soil and even soil PH. Each plant community is going to live in different soils as well as have an effect on those soils. This adds another level complexity to our soils.
This is all a lot to absorb! There is so much that goes into making each soil what it is. Something as simple as a soil test cannot truly tell you what is going on in your soil. In fact different kinds of soil tests have different accuracy levels depending on what kind of soil they are being used in. (Soil tests are a whole other subject to get into. Maybe we will cover that at a later time.)
The point is that trying to reduce soil to a simple test or any other reductionist scientific method will always fall short of reality. They are so many variables and factors that affect how soils work that we are likely not aware of them all. That's not to say we shouldn't try to understand what is going on or that scientific study has no value. That's not what I am saying at all!
We just need to be aware of our limitations. That is why I prefer to look at basic principles like having good soil aggregation and water infiltration. I like to use microbes and carbon to fix soil problems as well as providing nutrients in relatively small quantities, but in very available forms.
By coming alongside nature as a friend and nurturing her, we get far better results than by reducing her to a formula and forcing our will upon the land. That has never ended well for humanity.
Nature is constantly changing and adapting. If we are going to care for her, we are going to need to be equally adaptive, flexible, and curious. Just like an artist...