03/09/2026
What to Pick First in a Remodel: The 7 Selections That Keep Your Project on Track
One of the biggest reasons remodeling projects feel stressful is not the construction itself. It is the decision-making. Homeowners are often excited to begin, but once the process starts, they quickly realize just how many choices need to be made.
At Olive + Baxter, we help our clients move through selections with confidence so the remodeling process feels exciting, not overwhelming. From concept to completion, our team is here to guide every step.
The truth is, making the right selections in the right order can keep your project on schedule, protect your budget, and create a finished result that feels cohesive and thoughtfully designed. When selections are delayed or made out of order, it can slow down timelines, create confusion, and lead to costly changes later.
Here are the seven selections we believe matter most at the beginning of a remodel.
1. Cabinetry
Cabinetry is often one of the first major decisions because it affects layout, function, storage, and overall style. In a kitchen, bathroom, mudroom, laundry room, or built-in project, cabinetry sets the tone for everything that follows. The door style, finish color, wood tone, and cabinet configuration all influence the look and feel of the space.
Cabinet decisions also impact timelines because they often have longer lead times than other items. Getting these selected early helps move the project forward smoothly.
2. Countertops
Once cabinetry is moving in the right direction, countertops are the next important choice. Your countertop selection influences color palette, edge detail, maintenance level, and the overall visual weight of the room.
Whether a client loves the look of quartz, natural stone, or something timeless and understated, this choice helps connect the cabinetry, backsplash, flooring, and paint into one complete plan.
3. Flooring
Flooring is one of the most important foundational selections in any remodel. It affects durability, comfort, maintenance, and flow from one room to the next. It also plays a huge role in how warm, light, or modern the finished home feels.
Choosing flooring early allows the rest of the design to build around it. It is much easier to coordinate cabinetry, tile, paint, and furnishings when you already know the flooring direction.
4. Tile
Tile is where personality and detail often come alive. Whether it is a kitchen backsplash, shower walls, bathroom floor, fireplace surround, or accent detail, tile adds texture, shape, color, and movement.
Because there are so many beautiful options, this is also where clients can get overwhelmed. That is why having a designer guide the process makes such a difference. Tile should not just be pretty on its own. It needs to work with the full design plan.
5. Plumbing Fixtures
Faucets, shower trim, tub fillers, sinks, and other plumbing fixtures may seem like finishing touches, but they should be selected early. These choices affect rough-in planning, finish coordination, and overall design consistency.
From polished nickel to matte black to satin brass, plumbing finishes help define the style of the room. They also need to coordinate with cabinetry hardware, lighting, and other details for a polished final look.
6. Lighting
Lighting is one of the most overlooked parts of remodeling, but it has the power to completely transform a space. The right lighting adds beauty, function, and mood. It can make a room feel elevated, warm, dramatic, or welcoming.
Selecting lighting early allows for proper electrical planning and ensures that decorative fixtures and recessed lighting work together. Great design is not just about what you see in daylight. It is also about how the home feels when the lights come on.
7. Paint Colors
Paint may come later in the construction timeline, but color direction should be considered much earlier. Paint ties everything together. It helps balance warm and cool tones, soften bold materials, and bring harmony to the entire project.
The perfect paint color is rarely chosen in isolation. It should relate to the flooring, cabinetry, countertops, tile, and lighting so the finished space feels intentional and complete.
Why the Order Matters
When selections are made in the right sequence, everything works better. The project stays more organized. Materials arrive when they should. Trades have what they need. The design feels cohesive instead of pieced together.
This is one of the reasons clients appreciate working with Olive + Baxter. We do not leave homeowners to figure it all out on their own. We guide the process, help narrow down choices, and create a plan that feels manageable and exciting.
A remodel should not feel like a guessing game. It should feel like a well-thought-out journey that leads to a beautiful result.
At Olive + Baxter, we help our clients move through selections with confidence so the remodeling process feels exciting—not overwhelming. From concept to completion, our team is here to guide every step.
535 S. Washington St, Suite 7
Naperville, Illinois
630-519-6277
oliveandbaxter.com