03/25/2024
So I get this call from a contractor in the UP . They have a large house up there that’s being “restored”. Supposedly there was a fire and it ruined the woodwork.
Predominantly wainscot through the whole house.
Everything was taken down to the studs. Then they sent me the before pictures and I see the wainscot was 6’ high, beautiful old growth white oak, most likely quarter sawn with an ammonia stain.
The ceilings were coffered, doors were 8 paneled.
They would like me to match the old.
They even ripped out all the hardwood floors.
I asked what they did with all the old woodwork and they informed me it all went into a dumpster. I asked why, and they said there was a fire and it was all smoke damaged.
😮😳🙄
Somehow I find this very hard to believe, that a fire would warrant that everything gets tossed. More likely it’s the contractors not wanting to deal with restoring any of the wood, wanting open walls to run their electric, plumbing and insulation.
Your typical Midwest American contractor can’t deal with restoring old wood, can’t deal with snaking electric and plumbing lines in older walls, can’t deal with patching cracked plaster, can’t deal with restoring old windows, and won’t mess with rehanging old doors.
You typical Midwest contractor is great at talking the client into replacing everything though, telling the client it’s all junk and can’t be restored, saying it’ll be more cost effective to replace.
So now they want me to wave my magic wand and replicate everything the way it was.
I’m sorry, but I don’t tolerate this bs.
They had it all there, and then like complete dumb asses they threw the historical character of the whole house into the trash, not saving anything. I asked them “what about the windows? “ to which I was told they would be replaced too. I asked “copied with the fancy sash designs?” For which they said “we have something close enough”,
Forget it, they’ll have to find some other sucker. I’m not gonna do it.
I don’t care what the pay is. They are stupid. You can’t get that wood anymore, nor can you make it the way it was made with mortise and tenon joints, floating panels. You certainly can’t do the ammonia whole house stain job. Good luck finding those floors too. You will never match those doors or windows in looks or quality.
I’m so sick of this happening in every Midwest city. American contractors know absolutely nothing about restoration, but think they are “restoring” a house by replacing everything, and then when it’s all done, they’ll be honored by the preservation groups with plaques and awards. The house will be showcased in the main paper as being restored when in reality everything but it’s bones were replaced.
Get this, will all this new work last as long as the original? Probably not. Windows will need to be exchanged out again after 30 years m. Laminate floors will certainly need replacing. Woodworking will have cracks and nails popping. It will never travel time like the original woodwork, and neither will the rest of it.
A colossal waste of money due to contractors not knowing how to preserve and restore.